







SAUGATUCK:
VILLAGE OF VALLEY
FORGE EMERGING (link at book cover)?
Norwich Public Utilities vies with private company for responsibilities
tied to dam construction and maintenance; drought elsewhere; how
about hurricane-related floods? World-wide problem.
Indonesia flood caused by, among other things, poor
dam maintenance. Dam in Greenwich September rains, 2011.
Dam News over the past years: why we
got interested in this topic...
State: Byram River dam is safe despite water spurting through wall
Greenwic TIME
Frank MacEachern, Staff Writer
Updated 10:44 p.m., Friday, September 9, 2011
Town and state officials are keeping an eye on a Byram River dam after
water spurting through its walls was noticed Thursday following an
unusually high amount of rain this week. However, a state
official says there is no danger to residents who live downriver of the
dam, which is located just north of the Comly Avenue intersection with
Pemberwick Road.
"We don't believe there are any safety issues there right now," said
Dennis Schain, a spokesman for the state Department of Energy &
Environmental Protection, which oversees dam safety in Connecticut.
"It's a really solid and well constructed dam."
The dam has been inspected in the past, Schain said.
"We are aware of the situation and we have been in contact with
officials down there," Schain said, referring to Greenwich. "It's not
unusual after the weather we have had to have some seepage through the
dam."
Dams, including this one, often will have what are termed "weep holes,"
to allow water to flow through the dam's walls to alleviate pressure on
the structure, said Daniel Warzoha, the town's emergency management
director.
"There has always been those weep holes," said Warzoha, who was first
alerted Thursday morning of water pouring from the walls. "They have
been there forever."
A dam has been at the location since the 1820s, but Warzoha didn't know
when the current structure was built. On Friday afternoon, water could
be seen coming through two areas near the top of the dam's western
side. But Warzoha doesn't believe this water is passing through weep
holes. He thinks some of the mortar that joins the dam's stone
blocks together has given way, allowing water to get through.
"We don't believe there are cracks or fissures," Warzoha said. "It is
water seeping through the blocks."
Even so, residents, including those downriver in the low-lying areas of
Pemberwick and Byram, shouldn't be concerned about the dam, Warzoha
said.
"We were working with state on the issue, and they shouldn't worry that
the dam is in a state of collapse," he said. "The water has come down
quite a bit."
Warzoha expects state officials, who have been busy with other dams
across the state, to inspect the dam on Monday.
"They had so many dam calls up state where they actually had failures,
they haven't been able to come here," he said. "They will have an
inspection team on Monday."
The dam is privately owned, Warzoha said, but he doesn't know who the
owner is.
"The responsibility rests entirely with the property owners," he said
about repairs or actions that may need to be taken.
Most recent pictures top left; click on map to get data about
what chemical composition of the sludge
is.






Photo shows apparent leak before Hungary spill
YAHOO
By PABLO GORONDI, Associated Press Writer
12 October 2010
BUDAPEST, Hungary – An aerial photo taken months before a gigantic
reservoir unleashed torrents of toxic sludge shows a faint red trail
trickling through the container wall — part of a growing body of
evidence that inspectors who gave the pit a clean bill of health may
have missed warning signs.
Police were examining the photo Tuesday as part of an investigation
into how part of the wall containing the 10 million cubic meters (350
million cubic feet) of caustic slurry could have given way without
structural weaknesses being detected by a team of inspectors from the
government environmental agency who inspected the container pond less
then two weeks before the spill. Disaster commissioner Gyorgy
Bakondi, appointed to the newly created post Monday night, said Tuesday
the inspections were under investigation, including claims by
environmental inspectors that "they had found everything in order."
As the police probe gathered steam, judicial authorities scheduled a
court appearance for Zoltan Bakonyi, the managing director of MAL Rt.,
or the Hungarian Aluminum Production and Trade Company, the company
that owned the reservoir, to decide whether he should be formally
charged, if so, with what, and whether he should remain in
custody. The photo showing an apparent leak of red sludge on the
northern wall of the reservoir — the same wall that partially collapsed
eight days ago — was taken by Interspect, a Hungarian company
specializing in aerial photography that invests some of its profits on
environmental projects, such as taking photos of locations in Hungary
which could be at environmental risk.
Interspect director Gabor Bako said he shot the photo June 11, nearly 4
months before the spill. He said the company shared the photo with
universities and environmental groups "but no further steps were taken
in the matter" until the wall collapsed freeing the caustic muck that
flooded three west Hungarian villages about 170 kilometers (just over
100 miles) from Budapest before being carried by local waterways into
the Danube River.
Although Interspect found many suspicious sites around the country,
"we're not construction engineers or specialists who could interpret
what the picture showed," he told The Associated Press, still hoping to
gather experts who could review the photos.
Bakonyi, the managing who was taken into police custody Monday, was
scheduled to appear at a preliminary court hearing Wednesday convening
at Veszprem, a western Hungarian city about 45 kilometers (27 miles)
east of the partially collapsed containment pond. A police
statement issued Tuesday suggested Bakonyi was guilty of negligence,
saying he did not prepare an emergency warning and rescue plan to be
implemented in case of an incident like the sludge spill.
There was no official information on what Bakonyi told police, with law
enforcement officials declining to divulge details on the progress of
their investigation a week after the start of their probe. By Tuesday
night, police had not made promised return calls to the AP. But
according to the daily Blikk, which is considered to have good police
connections, a lead engineer at MAL Rt., told police that the firm's
top management was aware — but kept quiet — about the risks of a breach
of the reservoir for an unspecified period.
The tabloid also revealed that in the 1980s, before the fall of the
Iron Curtain, Bakony's father, Arpad Bakonyi, was the head of the
environmental department at the ministry of industry — a predecessor of
the present-day inspectorate — and received several state awards for
his work. In an initial reaction after the spill, Zoltan Bakonyi
said the reservoir was patrolled daily and "did not show any physical
signs that something of this nature could happen." But Prime Minister
Viktor Orban suggested that preliminary investigations revealed
negligence playing a part.
"We have well-founded reasons to believe that there were people who
knew about the dangerous weakening of the reservoir wall, but for
personal reasons they thought it wasn't worth repairing and hoped
there'd be no trouble," Orban said.
Bakondi, the disaster commissioner, said that police had taken over
security tasks at all premises belonging to the company and that
production at the plant could restart during the weekend, although a
final decision had yet to be made. Bakondi leads an 18-member
supervisory committee, who will have to approve practically everything
happening at MAL from now on. The government rejected claims that
the it was using the disaster as an excuse for ruling by decree.
"This is not the nationalization of the company," government
spokeswoman Anna Nagy said. "It is placing it under government
supervision until the catastrophe is resolved."
Asked, however, what activities the company could carry out without the
consent of the supervisory board, Bakondi answered, "Nothing."
A corner of the reservoir at the alumina plant in Ajka, 160 kilometers
(100 miles) southwest of Budapest, the capital, collapsed last Monday,
releasing an estimated 700,000 cubic meters (184 million gallons) of a
highly caustic byproduct of alumina production, which is then used to
make aluminum. The Ajkai Timfoldgyar plant, which began operating
in 1943, was sold to private investors in the 1990s in the wake of the
collapse of communism.
MAL has a 12 percent market share in Europe of alumina production and 4
percent globally. It says it spent 30.3 billion forints ($153
million) in the past decade on maintenance and renovation work.
Media reports say it had revenues of nearly 29 billion forints ($147
million) in 2009 and 50 billion forints ($253 million) in 2007.
Officials: wall of Hungary sludge lake will
fall
YAHOO
By PABLO GORONDI, Associated Press Writer
10 October 2010
KOLONTAR, Hungary – The wall of a reservoir filled with caustic red
sludge will inevitably collapse and unleash a new deluge of red sludge
that could flow about a half-mile (1 kilometer) to the north, a
Hungarian official said Sunday.
That would flood parts of the town already hit by the industrial waste
on Monday but stop short of the next town to the north.
Environmental State Secretary Zoltan Illes said recently discovered
cracks on the northern wall of the reservoir at the alumina plant have
temporarily stopped widening because of favorable weather conditions
but will continue to expand, especially at night.
Disaster agency spokesman Tibor Dobson said engineers didn't detect any
new cracks overnight, and the older cracks were being repaired, but
that it was too soon to consider lowering the current state of alert.
Protective walls were being built around the reservoir's damaged area
to hold back any further spills and a 2,000-foot (620-meter) long dam
was under construction to save the areas of the town of Kolontar not
directly hit by Monday's disaster.
"I would describe the situation as hopeful, but nothing has really
changed," Dobson told The Associated Press. "The wall to protect
Kolontar is planned to be finished by tonight, but it will likely be
several days before residents may be able to move back."
Nearly all of Kolontar's 800 residents were evacuated Saturday, when
Prime Minister Viktor Orban said the north wall of the massive storage
pool — which is 24.7 acres (10 hectares) in size — was expected to
"very likely" collapse after cracks were detected at several points
along the dam.
The roughly 6,000 residents of neighboring Devecser, just north of
Kolontar, were told by police Saturday to pack a single bag and get
ready to leave at a moment's notice.
"This hasn't changed," Dobson said. "We are still on guard in case of
any more spills."
Red sludge is a byproduct of the refining of bauxite into alumina, the
basic material for manufacturing aluminum. Treated sludge is often
stored in ponds where the water eventually evaporates, leaving behind a
largely safe red clay. Industry experts say the sludge in Hungary
appears to have been insufficiently treated, if at all, meaning it
remained highly caustic.
Illes, commenting to reporters during a tour of the affected villages
and the damaged reservoir, confirmed that red sludge stored in
Hungarian reservoirs was not treated to reduce its alkalinity.
On Monday, the sludge flooded three villages in less than an hour,
burning people and animals. At least seven people were killed and at
least 120 were injured. Several of those who were hospitalized were in
serious condition. Around 184 million gallons (700,000 cubic meters) of
the caustic red sludge was released.
The red sludge devastated creeks and rivers near the spill site and
entered the Danube River on Thursday, moving downstream toward Croatia,
Serbia and Romania. But the volume of water in the Danube appeared to
be blunting the sludge's immediate impact.
Illes said that neutralizing chemicals poured into primary and
secondary tributaries of the Danube, as well as efforts to remove as
much red sludge as possible from the waterways, was able to prevent
ecological damage to Europe's second-longest river.
In Romania, local authorities were testing the water Sunday every four
hours in the village of Bazias where the Danube enters Romania from
Serbia, and will continue to carry out tests all this week, said Adrian
Draghici, director of Romanian water for Mehedinti county.
Romanian fishermen sailed out into the Danube and villagers fished on
the banks of the river for pike, which is plentiful in the Danube. They
seemed unperturbed by any potential hazards.
But local authorities warned residents about letting animals drink from
the Danube and urged them to be careful with fishing, as a
precautionary measure.
Hungary
fears second toxic wave
9 October 2010 Last updated at 05:55 ET
The Hungarian village of Kolontar has been evacuated after new damage
was discovered at a burst reservoir that spilled toxic sludge on
Monday. Prime Minister Viktor Orban said it was "very likely"
that an entire wall of the reservoir would collapse, releasing a fresh
wave of chemical effluent. Mr Orban also said there would be
"very severe" consequences for those to blame for the disaster.
At least seven people have died as a result of the accident.
Around 150 people were injured by the spill of up to 700,000 cubic
metres (24.7m cu ft) of red toxic sludge - many receiving burns.
Most of those killed were drowned or swept away in Kolontar as the
sludge hit on Monday. The village is the closest to the reservoir, and
would be expected to bear the brunt if there were a second spill.
On Saturday morning, about 800 residents were taken to a sports hall
and two schools in Ajka, 8km (five miles) away.
Rescue team spokesperson Gyorgyi Tottos said the new damage to the
northern wall of the reservoir was relatively minor, but villagers were
evacuated as a precaution. However the prime minister, in a press
conference at the scene, painted a more serious picture.
"It's in very bad shape and our estimation is that the wall could fall
down," he said. "It's very likely that it will happen... One
consequence is that human lives could be in danger."
"Behind this tragedy some human errors and mistakes must exist. We will
reveal all of that and the consequences will be very severe, tough, as
much you can imagine," he added.
Mr Orban said another 500,000 cubic metres of waste could escape if the
reservoir wall were breached again. This would be heavier and
thicker than the first spill, and would move slower - but would be even
more toxic, says the BBC's Duncan Kennedy at the scene.
Besides those evacuated from Kolontar, police were also telling
residents of the neighbouring village of Devecser to pack a single
suitcase so they could leave quickly if necessary. In the last
few days, residents and emergency workers have worked round-the-clock
to remove the worst of the sludge which damaged houses, streets and
farmland, and polluted waterways.
All life in the Marcal river, which feeds the Danube, is said to have
been extinguished.
The sludge reached the Danube on Thursday, but Hungarian officials said
on Friday that the pH level in the river was "normal", easing fears
that Europe's second longest river would be significantly polluted.
Emergency crews have been working to dilute the alkaline content of the
spill, adding huge quantities of gypsum and chemical fertilisers to the
waters of the Marcal and Raba rivers.
The disaster's confirmed death toll rose to seven on Friday, after an
81-year-old man died from injuries sustained in the torrent and two
bodies were found on the outskirts of the village of Devecser.
The victims were likely to be two of three Kolontar residents still
missing, disaster unit chief Tibor Dobson said.
The company responsible for the alumina plant, MAL Hungarian Aluminium
Production and Trade Company, has offered its condolences to the
families of the bereaved but insists it did nothing wrong. It
said it was devoting "all its energies and efforts" to tackling the
spill, and had released 110,000 euros (£96,000) so far to help
with the clean-up.
Toxic sludge almost the size of
Gulf Oil spill
YAHOO
By PABLO GORONDI, Associated Press Writer
8 October 2010
KOLONTAR, Hungary – The mighty Danube was apparently absorbing
Hungary's massive toxic red sludge spill with little immediate harm,
officials reported Friday — even though the amount of caustic slurry
spewed over the western part of the country was nearly as great as the
Gulf of Mexico oil spill.
Revising even higher earlier estimates, government officials said the
reservoir break at an alumina plant Monday dumped 600,000 to 700,000
cubic meters (158 million to 184 million gallons) of sludge onto three
villages — not much less in a few hours than the 200 million gallons
the blown-out BP oil well gushed into the Gulf over several months
starting in April.
"The consequences do not seem to be that dramatic," said Philip Weller,
who heads the International Commission for the Protection of the
Danube, by telephone from Vienna, when asked about harm to the
waterway's ecosystem up to now.
Prime Minister Viktor Orban said the threat to the Danube had been
eliminated.
"We managed to take control of the situation in time," the state MTI
news agency quoted him as saying.
But the risk of pervasive and lasting environmental damage remained,
with laboratory analyses organized by Greenpeace showing high
concentrations of toxic substances in samples of the sludge.
Greenpeace told reporters in Vienna Friday that the samples taken a day
after the spill showed "surprisingly high" levels of arsenic and
mercury. The analysis suggested that roughly 50 tons of arsenic, 300
tons of chrome and half a ton of mercury was set free by the spill,
Greenpeace officials said.
Greenpeace officials said the detected arsenic concentration is twice
the amount normally found in so-called red mud. Analysis of water in a
canal near the spill also found arsenic levels 25 times the limit for
drinking water.
With rain giving way to dry, warmer weather over the past two days, the
caustic mud is increasingly turning to airborne dust, which can cause
respiratory problems, said Hungary's state secretary for the
environment, Zoltan Illes.
"Wind can blow ... that heavy metal contamination through the
respiratory system," he said.
Government emergency services officials on Friday urged residents near
the toxic flood area to wear face masks.
The warnings conflicted with the view of the prestigious Hungarian
Academy of Sciences which said that while the material remained
hazardous, its heavy metal concentrations were not considered dangerous
for the environment.
"The academy can say whatever it wants," fumed Barbara Szalai Szita,
who lives in Devecser, one of the hardest-hit villages. "All I know is
that if I spend 30 minutes outside I get a foul taste in my mouth and
my tongue feels strange."
Officials with Hungary's national disaster relief service, meanwhile,
told The Associated Press that a fifth person — an 81-year-old man —
died Friday morning from unspecified injuries sustained in the flooding.
Free access to Kolontar, closest to the leak, was shut off to media
Friday, with officials saying the crush of reporters and TV crews was
interfering with cleanup work. Media members were being allowed in only
three times a day and assigned minders.
The red sludge devastated creeks and rivers near the spill site, and
entered the Danube on Thursday, moving downstream Friday toward
Hungary's immediate neighbors, Croatia, Serbia and Romania. Monitors
were taking samples every few hours Friday to measure damage from the
spill but Europe's second largest river, appeared to be absorbing the
blow due to its huge volume of water.
The pH level of the water where the slurry entered the Danube was 9 —
well below the 13.5 measured in local waterways, Hungarian rescue
agency spokesman Tibor Dobson told the state MTI news agency on Friday.
Dobson added that such amounts posed no damage to the environment.
A neutral pH level for water is 7, with normal readings ranging from
6.5 to 8.5. Each pH number is 10 times the previous level, so a pH of
13 is 1,000 times more alkaline than a pH of 10.
Emergency crews, meanwhile, drained a second industrial reservoir at
the spill site Friday to prevent a new disaster.
Dobson told MTI that 100,000 cubic meters (3.5 million cubic feet) of
fluid from a storage pond close to the burst reservoir was being
gradually released into a local river already declared dead in the wake
of Monday's environmental catastrophe. Gypsum was being dropped into
the Marcal River from helicopters to neutralize the alkaline effect of
the fluid, he said.
It is still not known what caused a section of the reservoir to
collapse, unleashing a torrent of sludge. Three people are still
missing. More than 150 were treated for burns and other injuries, and
10 were still in serious condition.
Crews looking for the missing drained a pond swollen by the muck Friday
but no bodies were found.
Toxic Sludge Engulfs Several
Hungarian Towns
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
October
4, 2010
Filed at 10:09 a.m. ET
DEVECSER, Hungary (AP) — Hungary declared a state of emergency in three
counties Tuesday after a flood of toxic red sludge from an alumina
plant engulfed several towns and burned people through their clothes.
One official called it "an ecological disaster" that may threaten the
Danube and other key rivers.
The toll rose to four dead, six missing and at least 120 people injured
after a reservoir failed Monday at the Ajkai Timfoldgyar plant in Ajka,
a town 100 miles (160 kilometers) southwest of Budapest, the capital.
Several hundred tons of plaster were being poured into the Marcal River
to bind the toxic sludge and prevent it from flowing on, the National
Disaster Management Directorate said.
So far, about 35.3 million cubic feet (1 million cubic meters) of
sludge has leaked from the reservoir, affecting an estimated 15.4
square miles (40 square kilometers), Environmental Affairs State
Secretary Zoltan Illes told the state news wire MTI.
Illes called the flood an "ecological catastrophe" and said the sludge
could reach the Raba and Danube rivers. He suspended activity at the
plant and ordered the company to repair the damaged reservoir.
The disaster agency said 390 residents had to be temporarily relocated
and 110 were rescued from the flooded towns, including Kolontal,
Devecser and Somlovasarhely. Firefighters and soldiers swept through
the region Tuesday carrying out cleanup tasks with bulldozers.
The sludge, a waste product in aluminum production, contains heavy
metals and is toxic if ingested. Many of the injured sustained burns as
the sludge seeped through their clothes, and two faced life-threatening
conditions. Two women, a young man and a 3-year-old child were killed
in the flooding.
The injured were being monitored because the chemical burns caused by
the sludge could take days to emerge and what may seem like superficial
injuries could later cause damage to deeper tissue, Dr. Peter Jakabos
of Gyor hospital, where several of the injured were taken, told state
television.
In Devecser, the sludge in Tunde Erdelyi's house was still five feet
(1.5 meters) high Tuesday and rescue workers had to use an ax to cut
through her living room door to let the red liquid flow out.
"When I heard the rumble of the flood, all the time I had was to jump
out the window and run to higher ground," said a tearful Erdelyi, still
shocked by the events but grateful that the family rabbit and cat were
safe.
Robert Kis, Erdelyi's husband, said his uncle had been taken to
Budapest by helicopter after the sludge "burned him to the bone." The
toxic flood overturned Erdelyi's car and pushed it 30 yards (meters) to
the back of the garden while her husband's van was lifted up onto a
fence.
Erdelyi, a seamstress, was hoping the flood spared the shop in town
where she worked, her family's main source of income.
In neighboring Kolontal, the town closest to the aluminum plant,
61-year old widow Erzsebet Veingartner was in her kitchen when the
sludge flood hit Monday afternoon.
"I looked outside and all I saw was the stream swelling like a huge
wave," said Veingartner, who lives on a monthly disability pension of
70,000 forints ($350). "Thank God I had the presence of mind to turn
off the gas and run up to the attic."
Veingartner, devastated by her losses, looked out at her backyard still
covered by some three yards (meters) of red sludge.
"I have a winter's worth of firewood in the basement and it's all
useless now," she said. "I lost all my chickens, my ducks, my
Rottweiler, and my potato patch. My late husband's tools and machinery
were in the shed and it's all gone."
Local environmentalists say they have tried to call the government's
attention to the risks of red sludge for years, pointing to a 2003
report in which they estimated the waste at 30 million tons.
"Accumulated during decades ... red sludge is, by volume, the largest
amount of toxic waste in Hungary," the Clear Air Action Group said,
adding that producing one ton of alumina resulted in two tons of toxic
waste.
MAL Rt., the Hungarian Aluminum Production and Trade Company that owns
the Ajka plant, said that according to European Union standards, the
red sludge was not considered toxic waste. The company also denied that
it should have taken more precautions to shore up the reservoir.
"According to the current evaluation, company management could not have
noticed the signs of the natural catastrophe nor done anything to
prevent it even while carefully respecting technological procedures,"
MAL said in a statement.


Samuel Senior Dam in Weston not a levee,
fortunately. Being "down stream" has its disadvantages.
Residents flee homes as Wis. levee starts
to fail
YAHOO
Monday, September 27, 2010
PORTAGE, Wis. – Some residents in the central Wisconsin town of Portage
fled their homes after a levee started to fail, sending water from the
rain-swollen Wisconsin River onto a major roadway in one neighborhood
and threatening to leave some people stranded in their houses.
It wasn't clear how many of the roughly 300 residents remained in the
Blackhawk Park area after the only road into and out of the
neighborhood was closed. Officials said part of the levee south of
Highway 33 had eroded Sunday and water was leaking out, although the
levee had not completely collapsed.
Kathy Matavka said she was taken from her home by boat after she
received a second call urging her to evacuate.
"If I didn't sit there and take the boat, I would be stuck. I would not
be able to get groceries. I would not be able to get medications I need
to take," Matavka told WISC-TV in Madison.
The levee is part of the Caledonia-Lewiston Levee System — several
dikes built mainly out of sand during the 1890s by homeowners living
near the river, according to the Wisconsin Department of Natural
Resources.
Kevin Remus told the Portage Daily Register that he and his wife
decided to leave their home with their 17-month-old daughter because
they were concerned about being cut off from the outside word. Their
house wasn't likely to flood because it's on a hill, but the access
road was already covered in 6 inches of water by the time the family
was ready to leave.
His wife, Lindsay, said the family planned to stay in a motel for a few
days.
"It's kind of a feeling of hopelessness," she said. "The water is out
of control."
The Wisconsin River is swollen from thunderstorms last week that dumped
several inches of rain in southern Minnesota and central Wisconsin.
The Columbia County Emergency Management Office warned residents in the
Blackhawk Park area that emergency vehicles, including police, fire and
ambulances, would not be able to reach those who stayed behind.
"The residents down there are used to having high water and dealing
with high water a lot but this could be something that they've never
seen, with this amount of water," said Kathy Johnson, deputy director
of the Columbia County Emergency Management Office.
Johnson said those who evacuated might be out of their homes for up to
a week, and the Red Cross opened a shelter at a local church.
Elsewhere, in the small South Dakota town of Renner, just north of
Sioux Falls, thousands of sandbags were being filled to deal with any
unexpected rise of the Big Sioux River.
The National Weather Service expects the river to crest Monday morning
about 4 feet over flood stage.
Scores Missing After Indonesia
Dam Bursts; 77 Dead
NYTIMES
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Filed at 8:12 a.m. ET
March
28, 2009
CIRENDEU, Indonesia (AP) -- Soldiers and police dug through piles of
mud and debris Saturday in a desperate search for survivors after a
flood from a burst dam killed at least 77 people outside Indonesia's
capital. But they were losing hope the 100 still missing would be found
alive.
Days of torrential downpours filled a large lake bordering the
low-lying residential area of Cirendeu to flood level. A huge section
of the Dutch colonial-era dike tore away before dawn Friday, sending
more than 70 million cubic feet (2 million cubic meters) of water
gushing through the gaping hole.
Some residents said it felt like they'd been hit by a tsunami.
They accused authorities of ignoring warning signs and failing to
repair damage to the dam, claiming it had been weakened in several
places over the years because of prior flooding caused by blocked
spillways.
Hundreds gathered at nearby Muhammadiyah University, pressed into
service as a makeshift morgue, with bodies lined up in a row under
batik sheets. Mothers wailed as they identified their dead
children. Four field hospitals were set up to accommodate more
than 180 wounded, some with broken bones, head wounds and severe cuts,
said Rustam Pakaya, an official with the government crisis
center. The death toll kept climbing as soldiers, police and
volunteers dug in with excavators, hoes or their bare hands, reaching
77 by nightfall.
''We've evacuated almost all of the survivors from their houses,'' said
National Disaster Coordinating Agency spokesman Priyadi Kardono. ''We
fear most of the 102 reported missing have been killed.''
Family members were desperate, unwilling to believe the worst.
''Where is she? Where is she?'' cried Mulyani, 50, who was searching
for her missing daughter, Pungky Andela.
The 21-year-old student went to a Quran recital at a house at the foot
of the dam the night of the disaster and decided to sleep there because
of the violent weather.
''How can she be missing?'' lamented Mulyani, who like many Indonesians
goes by only one name.
Most of the water had receded Saturday, leaving behind streets covered
in mud and debris. Cars that had been parked in driveways were swept
hundreds of feet (meters) away, landing in parks. Sidewalks were strewn
with sandals, cooking pans and old photographs. Some left
homeless stayed in a local university hall on high ground.
''What we urgently need are mattresses, blankets, clothes,'' said Abdul
Hamid. ''I don't have anything anymore, all I had was swept away by the
water. I don't have clothes for my children and my grandchildren.''
It was not immediately clear what caused the accident. But many
alleged the 76-year-old dam, like much Indonesian infrastructure, was
poorly maintained.
''We need to find a way to take better care of these Dutch-era dams,''
said Wahyu Hartono, a former Ministry of Public Works official, blaming
budget shortfalls for the disaster. ''Otherwise, there will be more
problems like this.''
Aldi Rojadi, 34, whose house was damaged, said there have been reports
of leaks for years and that someone should be held accountable. The
Ministry of Public Works promised to investigate. But 30-year-old
Rohmat, mopping the muddy floor of his house, said he wasn't expecting
much.
''Whenever these thing happens, officials throw around blame,'' he
said. ''But really, what can we do about it? Nothing. We just have to
accept it.''
Seasonal downpours cause dozens of landslides and flash floods each
year in Indonesia, a nation of 235 million.
Dam
Bursts in
Indonesia, Killing 50
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Filed at 9:00 a.m. ET
March 27, 2009
CIRENDEU, Indonesia (AP) -- Torrential rain caused a colonial-era dam
to burst its banks outside the Indonesian capital early Friday, sending
a wall of muddy water crashing into a densely packed neighborhood and
killing at least 58 people.
The flood left scores missing and submerged hundreds of homes. Rescuers
used rubber rafts to pluck bodies from streets that were transformed
into rivers littered with motorcycles, chairs and other debris.
Officials predicted that the death toll would rise, delivering more
than 100 body bags to the scene.
''I'm devastated,'' said Cholik, 21, crying as he sat next to the body
of his 54-year-old mother. His brother-in-law also was killed and his
1-year-old niece was missing.
''I wasn't home last night. ... I should have been there to save
them,'' he said.
The earthen dam, built in the early 1900s when Indonesia was still
under Dutch rule, surrounded a man-made lake in Cirendeu on the
southwestern edge of Jakarta. It collapsed just after 2 a.m. when
most people were sleeping, sending 70 million cubic feet (2 million
cubic meters) of water cascading into homes.
Several survivors said it felt like they'd been hit by a
''mini-tsunami.''
Water levels were so high in some places that people waited on rooftops
for rescuers. Telephone lines were toppled and cars swept away, some
ending up hundreds of feet (meters) from where they'd been parked.
By mid-afternoon, hundreds of victims gathered at nearby Muhammadiyah
University, which was transformed into a makeshift morgue. Many were
wailing as soldiers and police brought in bodies, covering them in
white sheets of plastic. Cecep Rahman, 63, lost his wife, son,
daughter-in-law and granddaughter in the disaster.
''I heard a crashing sound and looked out my window,'' he choked. ''The
tide was so strong, like a tsunami. They were swept away. ... There was
nothing I could do.''
Health Ministry Crisis Center chief Rustam Pakaya and rescue teams at
the scene said at least 58 people were killed and more than 400 houses
submerged, some in water 10-feet (nearly three meters) deep. A
9-year-old girl was found unconscious on one rooftop after the water
receded, but she died on the way to the hospital, said rescuer Toni
Suhartono, adding the child's parents and sister were among dozens
still missing.
An investigation by the Ministry of Public Works will be carried out to
see what caused the disaster, it said. But Wahyu Hartono, a
former official at the ministry, said the 40-foot-high (nearly
15-meter-high) dam has been poorly maintained in recent years because
of budget shortfalls. After four hours of heavy rain the spillway
overflowed and the base gave way.
''We need to find a way to take better care of these Dutch-era dams and
dikes,'' he said. ''Otherwise, there will be more problems like this in
the future.''
Seasonal downpours cause dozens of landslides and flash floods each
year in Indonesia, a nation of 235 million, where many live in
mountainous areas or near fertile plains. More than 40 people
were killed in the capital after rivers burst their banks two years
ago. Critics said rampant overdevelopment, poor city planning and
clogged drainage canals were partly to blame.
Towns
eye dams as new power source to cut electric costs; Canton hopes
project will turn a profit in five years
DAY
Published on 7/7/2008
Canton - Dams that once were used to power Connecticut
industry are now being eyed by town officials as a resource to cut
municipal energy bills.
Canton First Selectman Dick Barlow, for example, wants to use an old
dam on the Farmington River to generate hydroelectric power. The dam,
and another down river, were built by Collins Co., a manufacturer of
axes, machetes and other tools.
The generators were scrapped when the factory closed in the 1960s.
The dam is a fixture in the town of a little less than 9,000 in the
Farmington River Valley where the river has become an attraction to
enthusiasts in kayaks and canoes.
Interest in using the dam as an energy resource resurfaced a few years
ago when a company received a federal license to install new generators
and use the dam. However, the company failed to deliver last year and
Barlow got involved.
His plan calls for the town of Canton to take over the license,
re-establish hydroelectric power and sell the energy to the power grid.
”It's a shame to have this sitting here with nothing but a pigeon roost
right now,” Barlow said. “Even if it makes a modest profit, it's clean
energy. Why wouldn't you try?”
Canton has approved $20,000 for a feasibility study of the dams. Barlow
plans to hire a consultant and if all goes well, he hopes to produce
energy within the next few years.
Each dam would cost about $3 million to refurbish, including installing
fish ladders to allow fish to move upstream, he said. The project could
turn a profit in just five years.
Ownership of the dam is a question. The town says the dam is owned by
the state Department of Environmental Protection, but a spokesman for
the state agency, said it's privately owned.
Mark Quinlan, a supervisor at the state Department of Public Utility
Control, said that with rising electricity costs, there is “definitely
potential now” to use dams to produce power and towns should examine
what's possible.
A WATERSHED DECISION:
Making The Call On Dual Dam-License Applications Is 'New Territory' For
FERC
DAY
By Claire Bessette
Published on 11/22/2007
THE FEDERAL ENERGY Regulatory Commission spent two days in the region
this week to begin an unprecedented process of handling two competing
license applications for the 2-megawatt hydropower dam at Scotland Dam
on the Scotland-Windham border.
The current dam owner, FirstLight Hydro Generating Co., and Norwich
Public Utilities both have submitted plans to seek the hydropower
license from the federal agency when it comes due for renewal in 2012.
The long process started this week with a two-day visit by FERC
officials to see the dam and hear comments and concerns from the public
and environmental agencies about the two competing proposals.
It turned out that more questions were posed to FERC on just how this
process of evaluating competing proposals from different companies
would be conducted. During a public meeting Tuesday at the Windham Town
Hall, Jim Gibson, a manager and regulatory specialist at a New York
engineering firm not connected with the project, fired several
questions that gave FERC officials pause.
The FERC process is precise and driven by strict deadlines. What if one
of the competing applicants misses a deadline? Would that firm be
kicked out? FERC normally requires numerous environmental studies for
hydropower projects. Could the two companies collaborate to use the
same study data? If they refuse to collaborate, would one company's
study be made public and thus available to the competing firm?
How would FERC make a company prove its claims to operate the dam at a
much more efficient and more environmental friendly manner? For
example, Gibson said, Norwich Public Utilities proposed adding a second
turbine to improve the energy output while also operating at a
so-called “run of the river” method using the natural flow rather than
holding water back for a time and then releasing it.
Allan Creamer, a fisheries biologist and senior technical analyst with
FERC, fielded most of the questions, adding apologies for the several
times he was forced to say “we don't know yet.”
This is the first time under the current licensing process that FERC
has had to handle competing license applications for the same
hydropower facility. According to federal law, the agency has the
authority to award a license to someone other than the owner of the dam
if the energy commission deems that to be a better application.
“We're in new territory here,” Creamer said repeatedly while attempting
to answer Gibson's questions.
Creamer said the entire licensing process is driven by timelines, and
normally companies adhere to the set schedule. In the agency's limited
experience with competing proposals, the agency has found them
reluctant to share data. Companies often claim the information is
proprietary, but once documents are submitted to FERC, they become
public.
And given the competing claims that each company is expected to make on
its proposal, FERC would require concrete plans and feasibility studies
to prove proposed energy outputs and environmental protections on the
river, Creamer said.
After the meeting, Creamer said FERC has had several competing
situations, but most are resolved before they reach the formal
licensing process. Only once, under now-defunct licensing regulations,
did FERC have to make a decision between two competing firms.
In 1999, Holyoke Water Power, a private firm that owned the Holyoke Dam
and the city of Holyoke both sought the license for that dam. FERC
awarded the license to the incumbent owner, but then the private
company ended up selling the dam and the hydropower rights to the city
a year later.
“It would have saved us a lot of headaches if they had just done that
at the start,” he said.
In the Scotland Dam situation, NPU General Manager John Bilda said NPU
tried to negotiate with FirstLight to buy Scotland Dam and two other
hydropower units, Taftville Dam and Tunnel Dam at the Lisbon-Preston
border, which the company had purchased from a Northeast Utilities
subsidiary in July 2006.
Bilda said FirstLight rejected negotiations, and the municipal utility
decided instead to try to seize control of all three dams through the
FERC licensing process.
On Monday, FirstLight Scotland Dam Station Manager Robert Gates led a
tour and open house at the dam. Several FERC officials, along with
representatives from the state Department of Environmental Protection
and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, attended the tour, took
photographs and noted conditions.
With the river at low levels, the dam was not operating, Gates said.
The dam currently runs on a store-and-release system. During low water
times, the dam shuts down except for minimum flow to sustain the river.
Newly installed trash rakes capture everything from branches and leaves
to car tires. When water in the 134-acre reservoir upstream of the dam
rises 2 feet, the dam resumes operation.
The existing turbine cannot operate at water flows below 500 cubic feet
per second, Gates said.
FirstLight's license application calls for keeping the current system,
but the company has said it also is considering installing a new
turbine that could operate on the run-of-the-river system, eliminating
the need to store water until it reaches the height needed to generate
power.
That proposal would be very similar to NPU's plan to install two
turbines with capacity to run at very low levels, even less than 100
cubic feet per second, Bilda said. The dam currently does not have a
fish passage. NPU proposed adding fish passage facilities, while
FirstLight said it would study the need and may propose fish passage
systems in new applications.
Melissa Grader, a fish and wildlife biologist at the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, attended the dam tour Monday. Grader said the agency
prefers run-of-the-river hydropower operations to stabilize the river
height upstream of the dam. The 2-foot fluctuations now may be
significant to wildlife and plants along the riverbank, she said.
Connecticut
Going High-tech With Dam Safety
DAY
By Susan Haigh, Associated Press Writer
Published on 11/26/2007
Hartford — If a major rainstorm soaks Connecticut, Wes Marsh will soon
know with a click of a mouse or a text message on his cell phone
whether any of the 234 dams owned by the Department of Environmental
Protection are in trouble.
After spending 26 years with the state's dam safety division, often
trekking through the woods and climbing around dams to look for
problems, Marsh will be able to use a new high-tech system to help him
quickly identify which dams pose the greatest public safety threat.
“There's actual alarms that will be tripped when rainfall amounts or
stream fall are exceeded,” Marsh said. “You will know what dams will
not need to be looked at.”
Connecticut is the first state in the country to use DamWatch, a system
invented by USEngineering Solutions Corp. in Hartford, to monitor the
DEP-owned dams. The system is expected to be fully operational by early
2008.
Joseph Scannell, president of USEngineering and a former senior project
engineer for Connecticut's Department of Transportation, said there is
a growing interest nationally to better monitor dams for safety and
rehabilitate aging dams — which he considers the nation's forgotten
infrastructure.
Scannell recently demonstrated the technology at the National
Association of State Dam Safety Officials meeting in Texas. He plans to
meet with a Homeland Security official next week to discuss the system
and how it can help save lives nationwide.
“If I lose a bridge, I've got to close it down. That's a disruption of
traffic. There's a cost associated with closing an artery,” Scannell
said. “If I lose a dam, I could lose 50 lives, I could take out a town.
The risk is extremely high.”
A 2005 investigation by The Associated Press found many dams in
Massachusetts, Rhode Island and Connecticut were not inspected as often
as they should have been, and some went years without repairs. In many
cases, private owners were reluctant to shoulder repair costs or
couldn't afford to. In others, the government was unable to act or
unwilling to spend the money.
If dams fail — as nearly happened in 2005 when heavy rains threatened
the 173-year-old Whittenton Pond Dam in Taunton, Mass., and forced the
evacuation of 2,000 residents — homes, businesses and lives are in
jeopardy.
Connecticut has spent more than $45 million to upgrade its state-owned
dams and beef up inspections since 1982, when the U.S. Army Corps of
Engineers reviewed the state's dams.
DEP is also spending $80,000 over two years for DamWatch. The money is
coming from a federal grant from the Federal Emergency Management
Agency. The state will then pay Scannell's company an ongoing fee to
use the system.
The DamWatch computer software program essentially monitors the dams
and alerts state officials, using real-time data, by e-mail, cell
phones, fax machines and pagers about the changing weather and rising
water levels. That information can be checked against existing data
about problem dams, flood zones and watershed areas.
In an instant, a user can also call up photos of the dam, maps and
inspection reports.
“I think it's unique the way he's put those components together to give
you a real-time look at what's happening to structures during a
rainfall event,” said Ann Kuzyk, a civil engineer in Connecticut's dam
safety group.
Besides the DEP-owned dams, DamWatch will be able to help officials
track potential problems at other dams across the state.
There are about 4,400 dams in Connecticut, most privately owned. Of
those, 503 could cause loss of life and serious property damage if they
fail. Many of those structures are in the same watersheds as the
DEP-owned dams and therefore can still be monitored even though they
won't officially be part of the system.
Scannell first designed a similar program called ScourWatch, a service
that helps officials proactively monitor the safety of bridges.
Tennessee, Connecticut, Iowa and Georgia are using the system.
While a DOT engineer, he grew concerned that foundations of bridges
often erode due to a phenomena called “scouring.” That's when the water
flowing under the bridge carries away the material around the bridge
abutment or piers. The problem can be exacerbated during a storm.
The problem is the same for dams — 85 percent of which are earthen in
the U.S. and more susceptible to erosion.
“What I envision is the agencies themselves can adopt the DamWatch
technology quite quickly and implement quite painlessly,” said
Scannell. “Right now, they go around chasing phone calls and problems
and they send their team wherever their crisis is calling them. It's
kind of a chaotic response. It's the best they can do at this time.”
Aquarion and Nature Conservancy in Joint
Venture
Westport
NEWS
By Frank Luongo
Article Launched: 11/14/2007 01:21:39 PM EST
In what is being described as a one-of-a-kind model for water-supply
management, the Aquarion Water Company and the Nature Conservancy (TNC)
have established a water-management partnership that will attempt to
hold sufficient water in reserve for human needs without denying an
area watershed the flow of water necessary for ecological health and
vitality.
At the water company's Aspetuck Environmental Center in Easton last
Thursday, Charles Firlotte, Aquarion president and chief executive
officer, and Lise Hanners, TNC state director, signed an agreement to
put together a team of freshwater experts for the purpose of developing
such a water-management plan for the Saugatuck River watershed.
According to information distributed at the signing, the watershed
covers more than 37,000 acres in southwest Connecticut and provides
drinking water for 300,000 residents of Fairfield County.
Eighty percent of the watershed is located in Westport, Weston, Easton
and Redding. The balance of the watershed is in Bethel, Danbury,
Fairfield, Newtown, Norwalk, Ridgefield and Wilton.
Those 11 towns and cities teamed up in 2004 with the conservancy to
form another partnership to reduce the stress on the river system,
resulting from such problems as pollution, invasive plant species and
excessive extraction of water from the Saugatuck River for commercial
use. Downstream from two of the water company's reservoirs, the
Saugatuck in Redding and the Aspetuck in Easton, the watershed is home
to diverse animals, plants and fish that rely on a natural flow of
water to flourish.
At the signing of the agreement, Firlotte said that his company would
be expanding its role as an "environmental steward" by using a computer
model to "determine the impact of water releases" and more closely
mimic the natural process.
This is the first time that the conservancy, which has a worldwide
membership of 1 million and has been responsible for the conservation
and protection of more than 15 million acres in the United States, will
be collaborating with a private water company to re-examine reservoir
practices to promote freshwater ecology, according to Hanners.
"We hope that Aquarion's progressive thinking will set the stage for
similar efforts by other private and public water suppliers," Hanners
said in a press release issued jointly with Aquarion.
Firlotte said that his company "understands that sound management of
freshwater resources is the key to maintaining the quality of life in
our region," and expressed confidence that the partnership would
"create a flow-management plan for the Saugatuck River basin that will
achieve both public water supply and river ecosystem health goals."
Stressing the need to follow nature's lead in monitoring the release of
water from reservoirs, Hanners said during the signing ceremony that
"creatures take their cues from the natural rising or falling levels of
river water."
She said, for example, that the seasonal changing of water levels in
rivers signals the time for fish to move to spawning areas for laying
their eggs.
On that point, Mark Smith, the director of TNC's Eastern U.S.
Freshwater Program, is quoted in the press release as saying, "Seasonal
high waters trigger spawning migrations in fish and provide them access
to upstream habitat. When these flows are reduced or stopped, fish lose
habitat essential to their life cycles."
He added that such reductions in river flows can also have a "dramatic
effect on wading birds, waterfowl and the diversity of plant life along
the river."
An added benefit of developing a successful water-management plan for
the watershed, according to Lee Dunbar of the state Department of
Environmental Protection's Bureau of Water Protection and Land Reuse,
would be less intrusion by state government in local water management.
"If we are successful with a good plan, the state will not have to
throw its weight around. If a local agreement balances water needs with
ecological needs on this scale, it will be the plan. This could manage
stream flow for years and years to come," Dunbar said in remarks at the
signing.
Officials:
Development adds to water woes
Greenwich TIME
By Hoa Nguyen, Staff Writer
Published March 3 2007
Bigger houses and larger paved surfaces might have had something to do
with the way many areas typically not known to flood were left
inundated yesterday by the 3.6 inches of rain that fell in just 12
hours, some land-use officials said.
"The highest concentration of calls we received were in areas where
development is ongoing," said Michael Chambers, the acting executive
director of the Inland Wetlands and Watercourses Agency. "They remove
trees, they create larger homes, tennis courts and other amenities. The
end result is what happened today. When you replace natural ground
cover, natural vegetation with impervious surface, the end result is
flooding."
Two compliance officers from the wetlands agency were busy yesterday
fielding calls and making visits to residents who believe wetlands
violations might have led to flooding problems.
"Most of the calls we received today were in areas in the center of
town, just above the Post Road, 1-acre zones where development is
fairly clustered," Chambers said.
When developers build houses, the land is replaced with pavement and
other impervious surfaces that do not absorb stormwater. To make sure
this water does not flood the surrounding area, engineered stormwater
systems are built to carry off the water. Sometimes those systems fail
or are deluged with more stormwater than they can handle, causing the
water to back up and flood the surrounding area.
"People who develop their property now are understanding the importance
of stormwater management," Chambers said.
Another factor that might have contributed to the flooding was the
frozen topsoil that prevented the rainwater from soaking in, allowing
the water to accumulate on lawns as if the surface were asphalt
pavement, said Conservation Director Denise Savageau.
"In places where there are lawns, we are just seeing complete runoff,"
she said, adding that is one of the reasons she advocates for the
preservation of meadows, which have crevices capable of holding
stormwater, rather than turning them into flat lawn areas more
susceptible to this problem.
Certainly the amount of water that fell within the short period of time
also was a factor. At the peak of the storm, nearly an inch fell
between 8 a.m. and 9 a.m.
"It just came in so fast," Savageau said. "It was the sheer volume in
the amount of time, it's one of those things you really don't have any
control of."
Both Chambers and Savageau said this is not the first time the town has
seen development exacerbate flooding conditions. In fact, the situation
could get worse as the area continues to be developed.
"We actually could see more occurrence of it if we have more
development of our watershed," Savageau said. "Even though we have
frozen ground conditions that are problematic, we still could see how
bad it would be if we had full development."
Officials keep
tabs on dams in town
Greenwich TIME
By Hoa Nguyen,Staff Writer
Published January 3 2006
Out of the 96 Greenwich dams registered with the state, only a handful
are large enough to pose a danger to downstream homeowners, town
officials said.
"We're very aware of those dams and we've been looking at them,"
Conservation Director Denise Savageau said.
Flooding is a perennial problem in Greenwich, although municipal
officials said it is more of a problem in low-lying or coastal spots
vulnerable to storm surges than just areas downstream of dams.
Still, steady rain coupled with storm surges had officials on edge
earlier this year about a particular dam in Glenville, after October's
heavy rains. State inspectors were dispatched to town and Greenwich
officials opened their Emergency Operations Center to monitor the
flooding potential had the dam failed.
In the aftermath of that potential disaster, Greenwich officials said
that their system of alarms and notifications worked to warn the town
and surrounding residents of a possible dam failure.
"That's the way it should be," said Daniel Warzoha, the town's
emergency management operations coordinator.
In October, officials declared a state of emergency when water from the
Byram River came close to flooding houses downstream of a dam at the
Mill in Glenville. Officials learned of the potential danger from the
dam's operator, who was monitoring the river's rising level and
contacted the town when it became time to open up the dam's emergency
bypass system.
That decision, which had the potential to flood several downstream
properties had river levels continued to rise, kicked off a series of
notifications, including to state dam inspectors, who arrived to
monitor the situation, as well as to various emergency management
officials.
Had the dam been overwhelmed, flooding would have inundated less than a
dozen homes. Still, a failure may have had far-reaching implications
for another downstream dam in Pemberwick as well as communities in
nearby New York, Warzoha said.
Greenwich was not the only municipality worried about dams failing. The
rain prompted Gov. M. Jodi Rell to order state authorities to inspect
rivers, streams and dams for potential flooding. This order was in
addition to the Department of Environmental Protection's annual
inspection of more than 600 of the largest dams in the state.
In addition to the privately owned dams in Glenville and Pemberwick,
the town also is home to several large dams owned by the Aquarion Water
Co. along the Mianus River. The rest of the dams are smaller structures
that do not pose a threat to downstream properties, officials said.
Dam owners are required to publish emergency action plans that detail
what they will do if rising water levels come close to overwhelming the
dams. They also are in charge of regularly maintaining their dams,
including keeping spillways clear of debris and watching for any cracks
in the dam structure.
"It's being looked at pretty aggressively," Savageau said of dam
safety. "DEP really has a good inventory of all the dams. When they do
the inspection, they send copies to the town, which we have on file."
While Greenwich officials said they keep regular tabs on dams, they are
more concerned about the general flood dangers that exist in town. That
is because while there are several houses downstream of dams, most of
the complaints they receive about flooding occur in densely settled and
built-up areas along the coast and near rivers and streams. Heavy
storms and surges of rain from events, such as hurricanes, inundate
these areas with so much water, while measures that keep flood waters
at bay, such as trees, have been cleared from the land.
Savageau said the town is identifying the conditions that exacerbate
flooding, from land-use patterns to meteorological data, to help them
understand how to address the larger problem.
"Our biggest concern isn't about dams, it's about storm surges from
storm events like hurricanes," Savageau said. "It's just a matter of,
there's so much water."
China landslide kills 128, hopes fade
for missing
NYTIMES
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Published: September 10, 2008
Filed at 12:51 p.m. ET
BEIJING (AP) -- At least 128 people were killed and many more were
feared dead in north China after a huge reservoir of iron ore waste,
illegally maintained and turned to sludge by heavy rain, buried a
bustling marketplace in tons of suffocating mud.
Two thousand rescuers shoveled and hammered through the debris
Wednesday searching for those buried under the three-story wave of mud
and mining waste that inundated a valley in Shanxi province's Xiangfen
county Monday. State media put the official death toll at 128 people
with 34 more injured.
Authorities have declined to provide a figure for the number of missing
people, saying an investigation is ongoing.
But the Shanghai Morning Post reported that hundreds may have been
buried in the mud. The paper said the landslide occurred in the morning
just as business at a busy outdoor market was getting under way with
shoppers haggling at roadside stalls for food and daily necessities.
When the dam broke, a wave of gray sludge inundated the valley washing
out homes, cars and a building where more than 100 people from a local
mining company were holding their weekly meeting, the paper said.
A relative of one of the company's employees told the Shanghai paper
that only three of those at the meeting were believed to have survived.
More than a hundred people kept vigil behind a security cordon, waiting
anxiously for news of their loved ones, state media reported but local
officials acknowledged that the chances of finding any more survivors
was slim.
''There were survivors on the first day and on the second day, but from
day three, it's very likely that anyone we find in the future will be
dead already,'' said a woman surnamed Dong who heads the propaganda
department of Xiangfen county.
Dong told The Associated Press in a telephone interview that more than
2,000 police, firefighters and villagers were mobilized in the search,
but conditions were difficult.
''There is mud everywhere,'' said Dong, who was speaking from the site
where excavators and front loaders were lifting earth and debris. ''It
is very hard for the machines to drive through the mud.''
Also hampering rescue efforts were the rough terrain, poor
telecommunications and heavy rainfall, which finally let up on
Wednesday, Dong said. Like many Chinese officials, she refused to give
her full name.
The accident underscores two major public safety concerns in China: the
failure to enforce protective measures in the country's notoriously
deadly mines, and the unsound state of many of its bridges, dams and
other aging infrastructure.
A preliminary investigation showed that the landslide was caused by the
collapse of an abandoned dump which had been turned into a holding pond
for mining waste by the illegally run Tashan Mine, said Wang Dexue,
deputy head of the State Administration of Work Safety.
''It is an illegal company that was using the abandoned dump to get rid
of its production waste,'' Wang said in an interview broadcast on state
television.
Heavy rains caused the already overloaded dump to breach its retaining
wall, Wang said.
''It was terrible,'' Wei Guanghui, a migrant worker who witnessed the
disaster, told the official Xinhua News Agency. ''The mud-rock flow
looked about seven meters (23 feet) high. It roared down the valley and
washed away the market and the houses in a few minutes.''
Nine people suspected of being responsible for the incident, including
the owner of the Tashan mine, were detained. Xinhua said several
officials, including the local head of the work safety administration,
the village Party secretary and village chief have already been fired
for negligence.

Dam Bursts In Grand Canyon
Residents, campers
uninjured as hundreds are evacuated after days of heavy rains
DAY
By Amanda Lee Myers
Published on 8/18/2008
Phoenix - Days of heavy rains around the Grand Canyon caused an
earthen dam to fail Sunday and created flooding that forced helicopters
to pluck hundreds of residents and campers from the gorge. No injuries
were immediately reported.
The failure of the Redlands Dam caused some flooding in Supai, a
village on a canyon floor where about 400 members of the Havasupai
tribe live, said Grand Canyon National Park spokeswoman Maureen
Oltrogge. The current floods and potential for more required the
evacuations, she said.
No structures were damaged after the dam failed about 45 miles upstream
from Supai, but some hiking trails and footbridges were washed out, she
said. Trees were uprooted, the National Weather Service said.
Nearly 80 people had evacuated as of early Sunday evening, said Red
Cross spokeswoman Tracey Kiest. Evacuations were still in progress.
As much as 8 inches of rain since Friday caused trouble even before the
dam burst. A private boating party of 16 people was stranded on a ledge
at the confluence of Havasu Creek and the Colorado River on Saturday
night after flood waters carried their rafts away, Oltrogge said.
The boaters were found uninjured and were being rescued from the Grand
Canyon, whose floor is unreachable in many places except by helicopter.
Rescuers were trying to find visitors staying at the Supai Campground
and escort them to safety, Oltrogge said.
Evacuees were being flown to a parking area 8 miles from Supai and
then, if needed, bused to a Red Cross shelter in Peach Springs, about
60 miles southwest of Supai, the spokeswoman said.
The area got 3 to 6 inches of ran Friday and Saturday and got about 2
more on Sunday, said Daryl Onton, a National Weather Service
meteorologist in Flagstaff.
”That's all it took - just a few days of very heavy thunderstorms,” he
said.
Supai is on Havasu and Cataract creeks about 30 miles northwest of
Grand Canyon Village, a popular tourist area on the south rim. Havasu
Creek feeds the Colorado, which runs the length of the canyon.
The flooding came on a weekend during the busy summer tourist season,
when thousands of visitors a day flock to the canyon for spectacular
views, hikes or to raft its whitewater.
The helicopters lifting residents out were from the National Park
Service, the National Guard and the Arizona Department of Public
Safety, Oltrogge said.
In 2001, flooding near Supai swept a 2-year-old boy and his parents to
their deaths while they were hiking.
The Grand Canyon has been the traditional home of the Havasupai for
centuries.